Poll Results: The 22 Google My Business Issues SEOs Want Fixed

Poll Results: The 22 Google My Business Issues SEOs Want Fixed
80

Google My Business is one of the most useful tools local businesses have in their arsenal. But while it is undoubtedly a must-have tool for businesses wanting to connect with customers, it’s not without its challenges.

Following our recent poll exploring which fixes our users want from Google, we wanted to drill down into the specific Google My Business issues that are causing the most frustration.

We asked our user base of SEO professionals and local/multi-location businesses to tell us which GMB problems they want to be fixed, as well as which of these they think should be tackled first.

The results below are based on the views of 310 BrightLocal users — thanks to everyone who shared their experiences with us. And, thank you so much to Sterling Sky’s Joy Hawkins and Steady Demand’s Ben Fisher for their expert guidance on the issues facing GMB users.


Which Google My Business issues would you like to see fixed?

Which GMB issues would you like to see fixed?

We asked respondents to share all of the issues that they personally want to be sorted.

The most prominent problems are reviews-related, with users wanting fake and contextless reviews to be fixed. A smaller (but significant) proportion are also calling for GMB to focus on detecting review spam networks.

A key theme of the results is that GMB users need more control over their listings. Which photos appear, the removal of duplicate and spammy listings, and usability of the new Google My Business Agency Dashboard were all named as major problems.

Communication is also in drastic need of improvement. 21% said they want the difficulty in contacting support sorted, with another 11% saying that responses are often inconsistent or inaccurate. Others want Google to provide more guidelines, and add extra functionality within GMB’s Insights.

We also found that GMB users want increased integration with Google’s other services: Analytics, Search Console, G+, and Data Studio.

Every single option of fixes that we put to our users was listed as a problem for some — meaning there are at least 22 changes users need GMB to fix to help local businesses. If you have any further changes you think GMB should focus on, let us know in the comments below.


Which GMB issues should be fixed first?

Which GMB issues should be fixed first?

Respondents shared the three issues that they felt needed to be fixed first.

While issues with reviews affect the highest number of people, these aren’t the issues that our users think should be GMB’s priority.

Verification of businesses is the most in-demand, while a lack of clear guidelines comes a very close second. False and no content reviews aren’t far behind.

When it comes to integration, Google Analytics is needed by the highest number of people — perhaps due to advanced users wanting more data in order to improve the visibility of their clients’ businesses.

If you’re one of the people crying out for more information, you may want to try out our reporting platform, where you can monitor all of your local SEO data in one easily customizable dashboard. Sign up for a 14-day free trial here.


Now and then

Back in 2014, we ran a similar study where users were asked which Google Places updates they wanted.

While GMB is often adding new and improved features, it’s clear that some of the themes from four years ago remain prevalent. Back then, duplicate listings (#1), verification (#2), Google Analytics exports (#8), and live chat support (#14) were all asked for by users.

Since then, we’ve seen plenty of great changes from Google, with features including business descriptions, GMB videos, the directions heatmap, Q&A, posts appearing in this year alone.

But if GMB doesn’t listen to the feedback from its users now, it will fail to reach its potential as the online meeting point for local businesses and their customers.


Your messages to Google My Business

We asked our users to share the messages they’d like to give to the powers that be at Google My Business. GMB, listen up.

Help businesses succeed

“With all the really smart people at Google, could they allocate just one to GMB that truly understands small business?”

“Just who is Google’s user? Business owners, consumers or the spammers?”

“Please remember that businesses use this product! You seem to only consider the user experience, leaving businesses stuck or scrambling to deal with changes.”

“The more difficult it is to manage Google properties, the more it perpetuates the shady perceptions of SEO and Digital Marketing agencies with SMBs. Their budgets are constrained, so processes need to be efficient.”

“I’m still irritated by the fact that online businesses fail to rank as well as brick and mortar business in 2018. After all, most service-based businesses don’t require a brick and mortar building, especially for very small teams.”

“It’s frustrating to not be able to update a Google 360 photo taken by the Google van of one of my customer’s DUMPSTERS rather than the business. I have loaded over 20 360 shots and complained numerous times over the last couple of months.”

Revolutionize reviews

“With all of the press coverage regarding fake reviews coupled with threads on the GMB forum, when will Google start tackling review fraud?”

“The GMB review system is clearly becoming vitally important for businesses, so it would be appreciated if visible efforts were made to ensure the veracity of this system.”

“Stop allowing fake reviews! There needs to be a way to verify the person is not only real but is an actual customer of the business they’re leaving a review for. Anyone can set up a fake profile to leave a bad review, and Google reps say that’s OK.”

Improve information

“Make it much clearer to understand how to get local businesses to rank.”

“Please be more consistent and transparent! It seems that the rules are forever changing and only apply to some.”

“Contacting phone support for Google My Business has to be the single most painful thing to do in dealing with Alphabet. If the intention is for someone to exhaust every SINGLE option, including getting a root canal, prior to contacting then mission accomplished.”

“Train staff correctly — I seem to have better knowledge of Google processes than many of the staff I talk to. If you’re going to offer ‘Insights’ let people display them by specific date ranges! Show improvements.”

Add extra data

“The more data the better! That’ll help us understand how users are using GMB and how we can make it better.”

“Merge multiple platforms G+, GMB and Google Mapping for businesses and create a process that cross-references addresses to avoid multiple listings.”

Simplify verification

“Making agencies jump through more and more hoops to get verification for business listings for clients doesn’t make the data more accurate — it actually makes it harder to get accurate data for businesses there, because the businesses have to depend on us for that.”

“I would like the verification process to be simple for the business owners. It is always a hassle to set up a certain time with the business to verify codes over the phone to give us agencies access to their account.”

“Agencies need better ways to partner with Google to verify listings. I’ve used the new video verification feature and the experience was absolutely terrible. We jumped through hoops for over 45 minutes with the rep and the verification was still denied.”

What do you want to see next from Google My Business? Let us know in the comments below.

Expert Opinion

"Google does listen to user feedback, yet we have to keep in mind that they are a machine learning first company and make decisions backed by enormous data sets. For example, while I cannot divulge the percentage, listing name spam may be of lower priority simply because the percentage of stuffed names are so small when compared to other larger issues like spam networks or location spam. Another thing that can complicate acting on feedback is the way the organization is internally structured. Product managers move constantly, and sometimes when this happens a treasure trove of plans could get lost in the translation. Keep submitting feedback (yes they do read it), continue to report problems via Twitter, Facebook and the Advertiser Community (again, this is all tracked).

Ben Fisher Steady Demand
Ben Fisher Steady Demand
Share this article

8 thoughts on “Poll Results: The 22 Google My Business Issues SEOs Want Fixed”

  1. Google is user-focused and Local SEO’s and businesses will have more success by explaining not only how they get impacted by those issues, but also how Google’s users are impacted.

    I am surprised that AdWords is not mentioned. The integration does exist but tracking / data is very poor and limited.

  2. I appreciated Ben’s comments at the end of the article. Very helpful. The fake reviews have gotten out of hand and the name spam is epic.. But there are bigger issues in the world and a slow and steady approach by Google and local SEO’s at least gives hope for the future of these problems. Thanks for putting such a nice opinion poll together about such a valuable topic!

    1. Thanks for your comment Josh – yes Ben’s insights were incredibly useful in understanding where GMB’s priorities lie!

  3. I have an account with a negative review. I looked at who left the review and that person left several negative reviews, at the same time, for other Attorneys in the area.
    I reported it and still nothing has been done.
    I’ve been seeing paid requests for Google Local Guides to use their statuses to leave negative and positive reviews.
    I hope this issue is going to be dealt with soon because like this article says, Google is one of the best tools companies have to increase business.
    All that said, I recently wrote an article on why people should not put too much worry into a few bad reviews. They happen and I think it’s common knowledge that you can’t make everyone happy all the time.
    That’s for real reviews though.
    These fake reviews are a huge issue and I think it’s only begun.

    1. Hi Andrea, thanks for your comment and for sharing your experience.

      It’s particularly startling that Local Guides are being coerced into behaving unethically with reviews. You’d think that this is the sort of thing Google would aim to stamp out right away as it erodes faith in the status.

      Yes, it takes enough time to manage and respond to genuine reviews, let alone trying to get fake reviews removed. I don’t know if you’ve read this article but there may well be something helpful here: https://www.brightlocal.com/2018/06/28/fake-reviews-impact-and-how-to-combat/

      Good luck fighting fake reviews!

      Jamie

  4. Wait so this survey shows that people want to have control over their online presence, I am shocked. In all seriousness, with all the issues revolving around fake reviews, I keep asking who is Google’s user, The business owner, the consumer or the spammer? Sadly it is the spammer and they are winning. I and others have been banging the fake review clean up drum for a long time in hopes of bringing about much-needed changes. It is easier to remove a fake listing than to remove an obvious fake review. 33% want fake reviews to be addressed by Google. The GMB forum is filled with complaints pertaining to fake reviews. Fake reviews are illegal and are punishable by fines from The FTC. Since it is illegal, why doesn’t Google take more of an active role policing it. At least consumers are starting to become more skeptical of online reviews. The ball is still in Google’s court.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.