NEW FREE VIDEO COURSE: Essential Google Business Profile Tasks for Agencies

Get the lowdown on client onboarding, GBP monitoring, products and services, and more!

Local Consumer Review Survey 2014

Local Consumer Review Survey 2014

Welcome to findings of the BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey 2014. To see the latest data on online customer reviews, see the 2019 Local Consumer Review Survey.

This survey is an annual exploration into how consumers read & use online reviews. It seeks to quantify the value that users place on the reviews they read & how this impacts their opinions & actions when seeking a local business to use. The survey is specifically concerned with the reviews & purchase of local business services and not wider product reviews.

About the Local Consumer Review Survey 2014

This is the 4th year the Local Consumer Review survey has been conducted. This year’s survey has evolved from 2013 with 2 new questions added & 3 removed which we felt were no longer relevant or useful for SMBs & SEOs to understand.

As with the 2013 survey, the focus of this year’s survey is on consumers in the North American market. We contacted our Local Consumer Panel which consists of just under 5,000 individual consumers, and received 2,104 entries with 90% of respondents coming from the US and 10% from Canada. The survey was conducted over 6 weeks in May-June 2014.


Consumption of online reviews

Trust & influence

Reputation traits

Incentive to recommend

Consumption of online reviews

1. How many times have you used the internet to find a local business in the last 12 months?


Using internet looking for business

Key Findings:

  • 57% have searched online for a local business more than 6 times / year
  • 39% have searched online for local businesses at least 1 time per month
  • 15% have searched online for a local business almost every day


The majority of consumers (57%) have searched online for a local business more than 6 times in the last year – that’s at least every other month. This is slightly up on 2013 – 56%.

Most significantly there is a 8% jump in the number of respondents who go online to find a business multiple times each week (7% to 15%) which points to more habitual use of the internet to find a local business.

Consumers are becoming more comfortable using the internet to find businesses on both PC & mobile. There are more & better services for locating businesses which make it faster, easier & better for consumers. It’s habit forming and they start to use it with increasing regularity.

Part of this growth can be attributed to more local businesses building & improving their online presence. Local data is more abundant & increasingly accurate which delivers better experience for consumers – i.e. they have a great selection of businesses to consider with lots of information to make in informed decision.

2. Select the Business Types you have searched for via the internet in the last 12 months? (select as many as you like)


Business types search in the internet

Key Findings:

  • More people are searching for more types of businesses in 2014 vs 2013
  • Restaurant / Cafe – 58% of consumers searched for restaurants (down from 67% in 2013)
  • Doctor / Dentist – 38% (up from 35%)
  • General shop – 36% (up from 35%)
  • Clothes Shop – 34% (up from 28%)


Looking at the year on year trend, more people are searching online for a wider range of business types than they were 12 months ago. Across almost all business types the number of people searching for that type of business went up. As consumers get increasingly comfortable searching for certain types of business they transfer this behaviour into other areas.

Interestingly the number of people searching for Restaurant / Cafes is significantly down on 2013. However we don’t believe that this should set alarm bells ringing for those in this industry. This is still the no 1 searched for business type and this dip may be more reflective of this year’s respondents vs 2013.

Overall the results show that lifestyle businesses attract the most searches. As these business are frequented by a huge number of people & more frequently than other businesses this isn’t surprising (more visits = more times to search) and follows the 2013 findings.

3. Do you read online customer reviews to determine whether a local business is a good business?


Reading online customer reviews

Key Findings:

  • 88% have read reviews to determine the quality of a local business (vs. 85% in 2013)
  • 39% read reviews on a regular basis (vs. 32% in 2013)
  • Only 12% do not read reviews (vs. 15% in 2013)


Almost 9 out of 10 consumers have looked at reviews in the last 12 months to help them make a decision on a local business. What’s more, 4 out of 10 consumers do so as a regular action.

As consumers we are growing more accustomed to consulting reviews when we purchase all types of product & service – hotels, flights, cars, restaurants, doctors, plumbers…so why not driving instructors, realtors & gyms?

So for local businesses in all sectors, this underlines the importance of reviews & the priority that business owners should put on managing their reputation and ensuring their online reviews are plentiful, positive & fresh (more on this below)


4. Which of these business types have you read online customer reviews for? (select as many as you like)


Business types and online reviews

*% figures displayed are 2014 results

Key Findings:

  • More consumers are reading online reviews for more types of local businesses
  • Restaurant / Cafe – 56% (down from 61%)
  • Hotel / B&B – 35% (up from 27%)
  • Doctor / Dentist – 35% (up from 32%)
  • Hair / Beauty Salon – 31% up from 17%)

How many different business types do consumers read reviews for?

Reading reviews of different business types

Key Findings:

  • Consumers read reviews for 3.3 different types of businesses vs. 2.7 types in 2013


Year on year there is a significant increase in the quantity of reviews being read per consumer for different business types.

The local businesses we read most reviews for are restaurants / cafes, hotels / B&Bs, medical practices, hair / beauty salons & clothes shops, and overall consumers are reading reviews for 3 different business types.

Hair & Beauty – Interestingly the amount of reviews consumed for Hair / Beauty salons has grown the most significantly in the last 3 years. In 2012 it was 9%, in 2013 it was 17%, and in 2014 it is now 31%. A review may once been the action either remarkable or unremarkable service, but it’s now starting to become an integral part of the purchasing process.

Trust & influence

5. How many online reviews do you need to read before you feel that you can trust that business?


Trusting business through online reviews

Key Findings:

  • 67% of consumers say read up to 6 reviews (vs. 77% in 2013)
  • 85% of consumers say they read up to 10 reviews (vs. 92% in 2013)
  • 7% of consumers say they read 20+ reviews (vs. 2% in 2013)


This years results show that consumers are reading more reviews than last year with 67% reading no more than 6 reviews (vs 77% in 2013). Significantly, a greater proportion of consumers are reading more than 20 reviews before they feel they can trust a local business.

This increased consumption can be seen as either a good or bad shift for online review companies. Demand & engagement is up but does this mean that trust in online reviews has gone down? (more below)

For SMBs/SEOs the significance of these stats is that it sets a benchmark for the number of positive reviews that they need. With 85% of consumers reading 10 or less reviews then we need to ensure that we have at least 10 reviews to satisfy them, but more importantly that the most recent 10 reviews are all positive. If your most recent reviews are negative in sentiment & rating then most consumers won’t look beyond these to the better ones that may lie further down the page. It’s important to ‘manage’ out bad reviews and focus on generating regular, fresh, positive reviews.

6. What average star rating is too LOW for you to consider using a local business?


Average low star rating for business

*This question is new in 2014 survey.

Key Findings:

  • 92% of users will use a local business if it has a 4 star rating.
  • 72% of consumers will use a local business if it has a 3 star rating.
  • 27% of users will use a local business if it has a 2 star rating.
  • 13% of users will use a local business if it has a 1 star rating.


The data in the chart is a little difficult to interpret so we hope the bullet points above make it clearer.

It’s obvious that businesses with a lower star rating will miss out on attracting new customers, but with this data we can quantify that impact. The biggest differential is between 2 Stars & 3 Stars, with 72% of consumers willing to consider a business with a 3 star rating vs. 27% who would look at a business with a 2 star rating.

The jump from 3 star to 4 star is also sizable, with 20% more consumers willing to look at a 4 star business vs 3 star.

So for local business owners, you can clearly see the value in having a strong online reputation and how moving the needle from 2 stars to 3 or 4 stars has the potential to win you a lot of new customers.

7. How do online customer reviews affect your opinion of a local business?


Effects of online reviews to local business

Key Findings:

  • 72% of consumers say that positive reviews make them trust a local business more (vs. 73% in 2013)
  • 10% of consumers don’t take any notice of online reviews (vs. 12% in 2013)


We can see that positive reviews have a great effect on the perceived trustworthiness of a local business.

Generally, consumers are quite far along the purchase path by the time they start reading reviews. By the time they get to the point of reading reviews, consumers have already established their ‘need’ and which businesses can meet it; now they’re looking for positive signals to help them determine which business is the best.

So it’s clear that local businesses cannot afford to let their online reputation slip as any negativity will directly impact customer acquisition & revenue.

8. Do you trust online customer reviews as much as personal recommendations?


Customer reviews same as personal recommendations

Key Findings

  • 88% of consumers say they trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations (vs. 79% in 2013)
  • Only 13% said they do not trust reviews as much as personal recommendations (vs. 21% in 2013)


Local consumers are placing more trust in online reviews than ever before.  88% (vs 79% in 2013) trust them as much as personal recommendations.

32% will trust a customer review just as much as a personal recommendation as long as there are multiple ones to read (7% increase from 2013).

A further 30% say that they will trust a customer review just as much as a personal recommendation if they believe it to be authentic – underlining the fact that authenticity is equally as important as quantity.

In 2013, 21% said they didn’t trust online reviews as much as a recommendation, however in 2014 this declined to just 13%. Indeed the chart shows a favorable decline in ‘No’s’ since 2011, accounting for a 20% swing.

9. When you read positive reviews of a business, what is the next step you generally take?


Reading positive online reviews of business

*This question is new in 2014 survey.

Key Findings:

  • 57% of consumers will visit a local business website after reading a positive review
  • 72% of consumers will take some sort of action after reading a positive review


With 7 out of 10 consumers taking positive action to contact business after they read reviews we see the significance in having a positive online reputation. Review reading is one of the final stages in the purchase path and has a direct impact on converting would-be-customers into real customers.

57% of consumers will visit a company’s website, which highlights the importance of having a website that can satisfy the needs of those consumers. Earlier this year we did a separate study on what consumers want on local business websites. It was clear that displaying critical information such as products & prices, phone numbers & address details, as well as important company information, is essential in allowing potential customers to quickly evaluate if a local business meets their requirements.

Interestingly 22% of consumers continue to browse around. Either they consult reviews at a different stage in the purchase path or possibly certain business types have a different purchase profile which involves more in-depth, &/or facetted research.

Reputation traits

10. For which of these local business types does ‘Reputation’ matter the most when choosing a business? (select up to 3)


Reputation of different business types

Key Findings:

  • Doctor / Dentist – 47% (vs. 54% in 2013)
  • Restaurants / Cafe – 46% (vs. 51% in 2013)
  • Hotel / B&B – 30% (vs. 28% in 2013)
  • Garage / Car Dealer – 30% (vs. 31% in 2013)


Local businesses which offer a service that is most likely to affect our health, well-being / safety, or comfort, are those which we feel reputation is most important for. It is businesses that offer a leisure service for which this matters least.

Local businesses in the medical field or hospitality sector should take additional steps to ensure that not only do they have a good reputation, but that this is also clearly represented online via reviews, which we’ve already seen inspire trust in consumers.

11. Which of the following ‘Reputation-traits’ is MOST important to you when selecting a local business to use? (select 1 answer)


Reputation-traits of local businesses


Key Findings:

  • 27% say reliability is the most important reputation trait for a local business (down from 28%)
  • Expertise (21%) & professionalism (18%) are also important factors


A lot of online reviews will often highlight the perceived friendliness or courtesy of a local businesses. However, whilst these are positive factors, we can see that reliability, expertise & professionalism are far more important traits for potential customers.

Additionally, whilst accreditation badges are regularly used on local business websites, they are not necessarily as important in the eyes of the consumer. Far more beneficial would be to display reviews or testimonials that highlight the reliability, expertise & professionalism of that business. Value is also an important factor, but above that consumers want to know that they can rely on said business to ‘get the job done’.

We feel that local businesses can use this to better pitch their services to potential customers. If consumers value ‘reliability, expertise & professionalism’, then businesses need to emphasise these traits throughout all of their marketing efforts  – PPC, email marketing, on-site content, Google+ profile, telephone calls etc…

Incentive to recommend

12. In the last 12 months have you recommended a local business to people you know by any of the following methods? (select as many answers as you want)


Methods of recommending business

*We adapted this question from 2013, adding in additional options for respondents to select.

Key Findings:

  • 61% have recommended a local business to someone they know by word of mouth (vs. 72% in 2013)
  • On social media, 37% have used Facebook, 12% Twitter & 10% Google+ to make local business recommendations


Word of mouth is clearly the most popular way for consumers to recommend a business to someone they know. Elsewhere we can look at the contrast between the big two social networks – with Facebook favored over Twitter.

Whilst mainstream review sites like Yelp and TripAdvisor are popular for customer reviews, consumers prefer to give  recommendations to people they know on a more personal basis. Using word of mouth – or Facebook – is less formal, more social & a preferred way to keep in contact with friends.

Interestingly Google+ Local was only used by 10% of respondents. It has an overwhelming influence on the lives of search marketeers but it’s adoption by real-world users remains low. Consider the traffic volumes flowing through Google’s interconnected products vs. Tripadvisor, yet Tripadvisor was used by the same number of consumers to leave a review. This highlights how essential it is for social review sites to have an active, loyal audience.

13. Which of these factors would make you more likely to recommend a local business to people you know?


Factors in recommending business


Key Findings:

  • 68% say that they would be more likely to recommend a local business if it was reliable & professional (vs. 68% in 2013)
  • 44%  said that being ‘friendly’ & ‘welcoming’ was important (vs. 46% in 2013)
  • A further 9% of consumers would recommend a local business if asked to (vs. 12% in 2013)


For consumers, reliability & professionalism are the most important factors when recommending a local business. Obviously people want to sure that if they put the weight behind a business that it won’t come back to bite them!

Similarly the ‘friendliness’ of a business is also important. While many consumers won’t select a business based on softer factors like ‘friendliness’, it is important for those who leave a review. They don’t want to send their friends (or strangers) to a business that will treat them rudely.

Interestingly 9% of people will recommend a business if asked to by the business. This act is ‘frowned’ upon by certain review sites (e.g. Yelp) but simply by asking for a review 1 in 10 people will be more inclined to give you one. So if you have 100 customers a day/week then this may help you generate those all important 10 reviews.

Ross Marchant
About the author
Ross is the former Marketing Manager for BrightLocal. With 9+ years SEO and content experience, Ross spearheaded the marketing and CRM initiatives which focus heavily on creating useful and informative content. Ross coordinated the research program at BrightLocal which delivers unique insights into both the SEO industry and local consumer behaviours.